News 
 Local News 
 News 
 General 
 Architects back university heritage listing 

Architects back university heritage listing

27/08/2008 11:40:00 PM
SOME of Australia's most prominent architects are supporting moves to heritage list the University of Newcastle after being outraged by changes to the Callaghan campus.

The architects are angered by alterations to significant buildings and fear the university administration is destroying the famous "bushland campus".

Their concerns will be aired in a DVD shown to Newcastle City Council tonight in response to Newcastle city councillor Ian McKenzie's motion to investigate heritage listing.

Specifically, the architects object to recent changes to Staff House, which was designed by Professor Glenn Murcutt, who won the world-renowned Pritzker Prize in 2002.

Those on the DVD include Newcastle's former architecture dean, Professor Lindsay Johnston, Professor Peter Stutchbury, Professor Richard Leplastrier and Professor Murcutt.

Professor Johnston described some of the changes as "vandalism".

Professor Murcutt likened the changes to Staff House, which houses the University Club, to "Bunnings on a Saturday" and said as the original architect he should have been consulted.

The university felled trees including a Queensland lacebark planted around 1969 as part of a new outdoor eating area at the building.

"It's destroyed a building," Professor Murcutt said.

Professor Murcutt said changes to landscaping were changing water courses.

"It's to me an absolute desecration," he said.

"I just cannot believe that a body of intelligent people would allow this sort of thing to happen."

Newcastle University vice-chancellor Nick Saunders was unavailable for comment.

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

Comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
A proud Australian tradition -- "If it moves, shoot it; if it stands still, cut it down" -- continues in one place which should be a bastion, a guardian, a resource of knowledge on maintaining good human activity as part of a good environmental whole. Will we hear that the trees are "diseased", "dangerous", or "hazardous"? In 200 years the grand spotted gums and other trees should be growing old gracefully along with the buildings, to the enduring benefit of Newcastle and its student population.
Posted by Maybabe on 28/08/2008 10:21:19 AM
I love the "bushland campus" of Newcastle Uni, but Staff House is an ugly building, more like a casemate than a social venue. As for cutting down trees, the sign stating "For your personal safety, please use alternate pathways after dark" says it all. And "a body of intelligent people would allow this sort of thing to happen"? Please. bodies of intelligent people make all sorts of stupid decisions.
Posted by Grant on 28/08/2008 4:24:32 PM
What a sad indictment that this is happening at our university, where the best minds make the clearest decisions, or have I got it wrong? Put the place back together: elswhere we would call this vandalism
Posted by WD on 28/08/2008 5:00:38 PM
Councillor McKenzie and the architects are entitled to put their views but not at the expense of good sense and progress and not at the expense of Newcastle ratepayers. This issue is another example of Newcastle City Council resources being improperly diverted away from fixing important infrastructure and "chasing rainbows". As for the two Grand Spotted Gums that Maybabe is so concerned about - there are thousands more on that site and I expect these two will hurt the building and cost more to keep than to replace. Alison, have a look at Glenn's original concept drawings and see how the trees looked in these! Post the pictures in the paper!
Posted by priscilla on 30/08/2008 1:18:05 AM

Post A Comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
 WORRIED: Newcastle city councillor Ian McKenzie at Staff House yesterday. Picture by Dean Osland
WORRIED: Newcastle city councillor Ian McKenzie at Staff House yesterday. Picture by Dean Osland
 TIMBER: Staff House before the trees were cut down.
TIMBER: Staff House before the trees were cut down.

5/12/2008 | I tell you about the banh mi to point out that we have room to improve that great Australian staple, the salad roll.
 
Life is a Journey
 
School Newspaper Competition
 
2008 Christmas Guide
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...