Opinion 
 Blogs 
 Jeff Corbett 
 Colin on the barbie 

Colin on the barbie

What was truly objectionable about Australia's whaling industry was the waste. Thumping great mammals were boiled down for oil and some other products, but tonnes of meat went to no or little purpose. Tonnes of tasty, nutritious, good-for-you meat. The number of whales towed into various whale-butchering bays around Australia between 1790 and 1978 would be hard to believe. One figure will give you a sense of the waste - between 1950 and 1962, just 12 years, 12,500 humpback whales were processed on the east coast!

Since Australia stopped whaling in 1978, much more recently than people realise, we have become aware of the passion of the Japanese for whale meat, and at the same time our tastes in food have become much more international.

I believe Colin the baby humpback has come along at the right time. Let's eat him, which will put him out of his motherless misery and put us in tune with the Japanese at the same time.

Eat him! Eat one of the whales that fill us with awe as they travel up and down our coast! We admire cows and we eat cows, and there's no reason why we can't admire their mammalian cousins, whales, and eat whales. We love many things in life and in death. At the very least we'll be able to berate Japan from a position of some knowledge rather than as a nation that slaughtered hundreds of thousands of whales without eating one of them!

Tell me, is there a moral difference between eating a whale and eating a cow?

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size

Comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
Jeff, I think its the same old story, people don't like the idea cause the majority don't like the idea. You have to spell things out like people are still in kindergarten for them to start thinking from the other point of view. I like your analogy on the cow, but we could go closer to the whale and say we eat fish. Hey there are some very nice looking fish out there, lets go get some sushi. I don't see a problem in eating the whale meat, hey, you never know, it may be nice. You never know if you don't try it.
Posted by nafe on 22/08/2008 11:05:03 AM
Whale meat IS nice, Nafe. It's sort of a cross between koala and platypus...
Posted by mikey on 22/08/2008 11:32:22 AM
I think whales and elephants are too majestic to consider eating but how about the horse, he's also revered by us all, but, sadly,truck loads of horses are slaughtered for petfood when they are no longer valued by their owners.
Posted by chaff and oats on 22/08/2008 11:35:02 AM
I say let's eat him.
Posted by Luke on 22/08/2008 11:55:33 AM
There is not a mammal that has not, or could not, be raised by humans if the mother has died or dissappeared. We could have given it a go! Nothing ventured nothing gained. It could have been a much better ending. I'm sure we have the knowledge and expertise to have done it. Self appointed experts procrastinated until it was too late. What we had was a baby starving to death before our eyes. And you want to eat it. This countries attitude to animal rights is appauling, caged chicken, live sheep exports, pigs on caged concrete in baby farms. It is disgusting, and again you want to eat a starving baby whale! We should have attempted to feed and comfort this distressed baby, Not eat it!
Posted by buell on 22/08/2008 12:18:18 PM
C'mon Buell, you know a whale burger sounds tempting. Bit of mayo and lettuce, maybe some tomato and cheese. Speaking of that, I'm going to get a fish burger, this topic has me so hungry :)
Posted by Nafe on 22/08/2008 12:44:17 PM
Buell, if you had seen the idiots that were trying to "save" the whale you would realise that this was the only humane thing to do. PS wouldn't mind having a taste.
Posted by Directeur Sportif on 22/08/2008 1:17:55 PM
I like whales but i couldn't eat a whole one. Eating whales is no different to eating chickens, cows, lambs etc. I find the thought of eating any living animal completely repulsive and wonder why humans think they have the right to slaughter innocent animals when there are plenty of vegetables nuts etc that we can survive on.
Posted by snr sergeant smith on 22/08/2008 1:39:03 PM
i concur snr sgt. I couldn't possibly eat any living animal. That's why we kill them first.
Posted by mikey on 22/08/2008 1:43:15 PM
I should have added if I was a meat eater I would have no problem with eating a whale.
Posted by snr sergeant smith on 22/08/2008 1:49:03 PM
1 | 2 | 3 | 4  |  next >

Post A Comment


Screen name  *
Email address  *
Remember me?
Comment  *
We invite and encourage our readers to post comments. Comments are moderated and will appear as soon as our editor has approved them. When posting comments you agree to be bound by our Terms and Conditions.
Jeff Corbett
Bend the online ear of the Hunter's most provocative columnist.

4:21 PM AEDT | Australians whose work justifies national acclaim, among them scientists and thinkers and entrepreneurs, never attain the fame reserved for people who pretend they are someone else to help easily manipulated people escape their own lives briefly.
Life is a Journey
 
Mecedes-Benz
 
Hino
 
See the world your way
 
 
 
School Newspaper Competition
 
Wine Country
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...